Elektrine lite

← Feed

@BlueMonday1984@awful.systems

2026-11-18 13:43 UTC

Another good critique of FOSS has come across my eyes: A critical mistake/misframing of the free software movement was deeming the bulk of software something desirable to make free from proprietary restrictions. The real missing freedom was freedom from software. Not being forced to use any software to interact with the world. (Recommend checking the full thread, its solid)

Replies (3)

  • @istewart@awful.systems 2026-11-18 14:47

    The second post in the thread is a great distillation and thesis statement: hachyderm.io/@dalias/117635183290482925 That is to say, the majority of the harm from proprietary software is not that it being non-free keeps folks who want to use and understand it from doing so, but that it’s systems of opaque rules people are forced to interact with in ways where not understanding those rules puts them at a disadvantage. Making it so a few specialists can understand the rules (by having the source) only helps minimally. I was thinking about this last night. From an end-user perspective, for example, subsystem-specific text configuration files in a top-level /etc directory and dotfiles in the user home directory are less opaque than the Windows Registry. But they are still non-obvious, non-standardized, something you have to spend time wrapping your head around that doesn’t necessarily offer skill transfer to anything else. The movement, such as it is, stood on pride that we had achieved a freely-available replica of something that was expensive, resource-heavy proprietary software in the 1980s, and never moved on from that. Backslid, even. What are we doing here?

    Open ##5555920

  • @schnoopy@awful.systems 2026-11-18 22:11

    Not sure I agree. Being able to modify software leads to people being able to use software which doesn’t have harmful aspects. You don’t have to understand a linux to just download fedora and abruptly escape surveillance. Or like download a list of adservers and software to route requests to 0.0.0.0

    Open ##5558793

  • @jaschop@awful.systems 2026-11-19 08:30

    I’ve long had the notion, that what I actually like about FOSS (and not all of it) is that it is genuinely intended to work in my interest.

    Open ##5559513