@kryptonianCodeMonkey@lemmy.world
2026-11-16 19:00 UTC
On a serious note, capital punishment serves absolutely no aspect of Justice. It does two things: 1. It saves the state the money, space and effort required to imprison a person. 2. It might make the victim’s loved-ones (if there are any) and the weird sadists of the citizenry feel a sense of closure (or sick joy) through revenge. Those things ate not justice though.
Justice is the correction of unfair, morally corrupt, and dangers to society. Of impridonment does not serve this goal, then it only serves, at best, pettiness, a lust for punishment, and the state’s bottom line over human life. Rehabilitation should be the first and absolute purpose of the justice system, and protecting the public from a real and present danger the second. If imprisonment is serving neither purpose, or, as is often the case, counter-productive to either or both of those things, then it ought to be dramatically and thoughtfully reformed.
Notably many people would argue that the point of prison is deterrence. And it isn’t like there isn’t a any credence to that. But the reality of human psychology is that, more often than not, we tend to follow or only slightly bend rules without any real threat hanging over our heads. And the absolute volume of imprisoned people in the US alone should tell you that this deterrence is, at minimum, unideally effective. And many crimes as done from passion, negligence, ignorance, addiction, poverty, or some other circumstance where you are either not considering the risk or forced to take the risk for the alternatives. If you are relying on the deterrence of the threat of imprisonment to rid the world of crime, you clearly need to rethink things. We need to be addressing the root causes of crime instead, and prisons designed around proper rehabilitation can be one small part of that.
Replies (1)
-
@funkless_eck@sh.itjust.works 2026-11-16 19:02
It absolutely does not save the state money. It is far more expensive several times over than imprisonment